The Understanding of Ignorance: Socrates and Rousseau's Two Views of Virtue
Resource
國立臺灣大學哲學論評, 33, 091-132
Journal
國立臺灣大學哲學論評
Journal Issue
33
Pages
091-132
Date Issued
2007-03
Date
2007-03
Author(s)
Abstract
“Ignorance” is generally considered a simplified form of expressing Socrates’ philosophy. Rousseau, once cited this expression in his Discourse on the Sciences and Arts, has explicitly portrayed it as the core idea of Socrates’ view of virtue. The main argument of this paper will proceed to prove that passages of Apology cited by Rousseau are not made intentionally to further develop his own ideas. Instead, they do manifest an essential part of Socrates’ view of virtue. Having proved so, we nonetheless aware also that Socrates and Rousseau remain to be different concerning their views of virtue. They both hold “ignorance” being crucial in ethical significance; yet differ in its reference. Hence, we endeavor to distinguish their views on the basis of the label “understanding ignorance to be virtuous”. In the order of this article, we will proceed to see first of all Rousseau’s citation of Socrates’ words. Then, we move to a documentary analysis concerning the divergent opinions about this citation. After that, we illustrate Socrates’ view of virtue by distinguishing Socrates’ own thought from that of Plato in the persona of Socrates. With this distinction, we then approach to an examination of “the unity of virtue is knowledge” and “the understanding of ignorance”. With a similar structure of analysis, we finally come to the exposition of Rousseau’s view of virtue. We will vindicate that in Discourse on the Sciences and Arts, Rousseau successfully extended Socrates’ ideas from “admitting ignorance” to that “nature makes all people virtuous”. With this success, this article, while making explicit the divergence of their views of virtue, demonstrates a “spiritual correspondence” between Socrates and Rousseau.
Subjects
蘇格拉底
盧梭
無知
德行
Socrates
J.-J. Rousseau
Ignorance
Virtue
Type
journal article
File(s)![Thumbnail Image]()
Loading...
Name
0033_200703_3.pdf
Size
22.58 MB
Format
Adobe PDF
Checksum
(MD5):0c43c67a02d19501f6d7f631343b5347