A comprehensive support vector machine binary hERG classification model based on extensive but biased end point hERG data sets
Journal
Chemical Research in Toxicology
Journal Volume
24
Journal Issue
6
Pages
934-949
Date Issued
2011
Author(s)
Abstract
The human ether-a-go-go related gene (hERG) potassium ion channel plays a key role in cardiotoxicity and is therefore a key target as part of preclinical drug discovery toxicity screening. The PubChem hERG Bioassay data set, composed of 1668 compounds, was used to construct an in silico screening model. The corresponding trial models were constructed from a descriptor pool composed of 4D fingerprints (4D-FP) and traditional 2D and 3D VolSurf-like molecular descriptors. A final binary classification model was constructed via a support vector machine (SVM). The resultant model was then validated using the PubChem hERG Bioassay data set (AID 376) and an external hERG data set by evaluating the model's ability to determine hERG blockers from nonblockers. The external data set (the test set) consisted of 356 compounds collected from available literature data and consisting of 287 actives and 69 inactives. Four different sampling protocols and a 10-fold cross-correlation analysis-used in the validation process to evaluate classification models-explored the impact of the active-inactive data imbalance distribution of the PubChem high-throughput data set. Four different data sets were explored, and the one employing Lipinski's rule-of-five coupled with measures of relative molecular lipophilicity performed the best in the 10-fold cross-correlation validation of the training data set as well as overall prediction accuracy of the external test sets. The linear SVM binary classification model building strategy was applied to different combinations of MOE (traditional 2D, "21/2D", and 3D VolSurf-like) and 4D-FP molecular descriptors to further explore and refine previously proposed key descriptors, identify new significant features that contribute to the prediction of hERG toxicity, and construct the optimal SVM binary classification model from a shrunken descriptor pool. The accuracy, sensitivity, and specificity of the best model determined from 10-fold cross-validation are 95, 90, and 96%, respectively; the overall accuracy is near 87% for the external set. The models constructed in this study demonstrate the following: (i) robustness based upon performance in accuracy across the structural diversity of the training set, (ii) ability to predict a compound's " predisposition" to block hERG ion channels, and (iii) define and illustrate structural features that can be overlaid onto the chemical structures to aid in the 3D structure-activity interpretation of the hERG blocking effect. © 2011 American Chemical Society.
SDGs
Other Subjects
human ether a go go related gene; potassium channel; unclassified drug; accuracy; article; bioassay; chemical structure; classification; computer model; high throughput screening; human; lipophilicity; molecular dynamics; molecular model; prediction; protein structure; sampling; sensitivity and specificity; structure activity relation; support vector machine; validation process; Artificial Intelligence; Computer Simulation; Drug Discovery; Ether-A-Go-Go Potassium Channels; Humans; Models, Biological; Models, Molecular; Potassium Channel Blockers; Protein Binding; Quantitative Structure-Activity Relationship
Type
journal article
File(s)![Thumbnail Image]()
Loading...
Name
A.19 A comprehensive support vector machine binary hERG classification model based on extensive but biased end point hERG data sets.pdf
Size
2.4 MB
Format
Adobe PDF
Checksum
(MD5):c39912d2f608e9aa800adf082f2a0c5c