Causal theories of the moving spotlight
Journal
RATIO
Journal Volume
36
Journal Issue
2
Pages
99-110
Date Issued
2023
Author(s)
Abstract
This paper brings together the Sarvāstivāda (a major school of Abhidharma Buddhism) and Miller's (2019) moving spotlight theory to see how presentness is explained in terms of causation. The paper argues that a causal theory of presentness like Miller's encounters a dilemma: causation is either synchronic or diachronic, but neither is safe in the presence of the challenges. On the one hand, if causation is synchronic, how does a causal chain extend over time so that the wave of causation (and hence the spotlight) can move at all? On the other, if causation is diachronic, then a present moment has a temporal extension enough to accommodate a cause and its proximate effect. The paper proposes a synchronic notion of causation that counters the first challenge. This can be done by bringing together the Sarvāstivādin grasp-production model of causation, some Stoic ideas about causation, and some Armstrong's metaphysics.
Subjects
causation; presentness; the moving spotlight theory; the Sarvastivada; time; BUDDHIST; TIME
Publisher
WILEY
Type
journal article