Hip fracture risk assessment: artificial neural network outperforms conditional logistic regression in an age- and sex-matched case control study
Journal
BMC musculoskeletal disorders
Journal Volume
14
Journal Issue
1
Date Issued
2013-07-15
Author(s)
Abstract
Background: Osteoporotic hip fractures with a significant morbidity and excess mortality among the elderly have imposed huge health and economic burdens on societies worldwide. In this age- and sex-matched case control study, we examined the risk factors of hip fractures and assessed the fracture risk by conditional logistic regression (CLR) and ensemble artificial neural network (ANN). The performances of these two classifiers were compared.
Methods: The study population consisted of 217 pairs (149 women and 68 men) of fractures and controls with an age older than 60 years. All the participants were interviewed with the same standardized questionnaire including questions on 66 risk factors in 12 categories. Univariate CLR analysis was initially conducted to examine the unadjusted odds ratio of all potential risk factors. The significant risk factors were then tested by multivariate analyses. For fracture risk assessment, the participants were randomly divided into modeling and testing datasets for 10-fold cross validation analyses. The predicting models built by CLR and ANN in modeling datasets were applied to testing datasets for generalization study. The performances, including discrimination and calibration, were compared with non-parametric Wilcoxon tests.
Results: In univariate CLR analyses, 16 variables achieved significant level, and six of them remained significant in multivariate analyses, including low T score, low BMI, low MMSE score, milk intake, walking difficulty, and significant fall at home. For discrimination, ANN outperformed CLR in both 16- and 6-variable analyses in modeling and testing datasets (p?
Subjects
Hip fracture
Artificial neural network
Conditional logistic regression
Discrimination
Calibration
POSTMENOPAUSAL CHINESE WOMEN
OSTEOPOROTIC FRACTURES
WHITE WOMEN
PREDICTION
MODELS
CLASSIFICATION
ENSEMBLE
MEN
Publisher
BIOMED CENTRAL LTD
Type
journal article