An Investigation into the Authenticity of the Bi-Lin-Lang-Guan Version of Jin Lu-Xiang’s Shang Shu Zhu
Resource
臺大中文學報, 34, 229-262
Journal
臺大中文學報
Journal Issue
34
Pages
229-262
Date Issued
2011-06
Date
2011-06
Author(s)
Hsu, Y.L.
Abstract
Jin Lu-Xiang is an important scholar in the Sung and the Yuan Dynasties. Allegedly, he is the author of Shang Shu Biao Zhu (Commentaries on the Chronicle in Shang Shu), Shang Shu Zhu (Commentaries on Shang Shu), and Zi Zhi Tong Jian Qian Bian (The History before Zi Zhi Tong Jian). Recently, Tsai Ken-Hsian has found out that Shang Shu Zhu is a fake: it is actually a part of Zi Zhi Tong Jian Qian Bian.
We currently have 2 versions of Jin’s Shang Shu Zhu, one of which is in Lu Xin-Yuan’s Shi-Wan-Juan-Lou Series and the other one is in Fang Gong-Hui’s Bi-Ling-Lang-Guan Series. These 2 versions are totally different, but few scholars have discovered this fact.
With a detailed investigation into all the documents related to Jin’s writing process of Shang Shu Zhu, this study proves that the Bi-Ling-Lang-Guan version is also a fake, because the thoughts that it includes do not exist in Jin’s time. This version is actually Chen Shi-Kai’s Shu Tsai Zhuan Pang Tong in the Yuan Dynasty, combined with related information as its preface, postscript, and appendix. It has been fabricated in the middle period of the Qing Dynasty.
Subjects
關鍵詞：金履祥、《尚書》、碧琳琅館Keywords: Jin Lu-Xian, Shang Shu, Bi-Ling-Lang-Guan
Type
journal article
File(s)![Thumbnail Image]()
Loading...
Name
0034_201106_6.pdf
Size
18.5 MB
Format
Adobe PDF
Checksum
(MD5):5ee217f9c050a39a05385b0eb8d85846