Repository logo
  • English
  • 中文
Log In
Have you forgotten your password?
  1. Home
  2. College of Liberal Arts / 文學院
  3. Philosophy / 哲學系
  4. O Utility, O Utility, What Crimes Are Committed in Thy Name---On the Conflict between Utilitarianism and Rules of Commonsense Morality
 
  • Details

O Utility, O Utility, What Crimes Are Committed in Thy Name---On the Conflict between Utilitarianism and Rules of Commonsense Morality

Date Issued
2005
Date
2005
Author(s)
Tsu, Shiu-Hwa
DOI
zh-TW
URI
http://ntur.lib.ntu.edu.tw//handle/246246/56433
Abstract
Many critics of utilitarianism claim that it would condone killing, stealing, robbing, and breaking promises whenever these actions are found to be expedient for the promotion of maximal happiness. It seems that utilitarianism does not take our commonsensical moral rules seriously enough. This charge is a serious one that threatens the plausibility of utilitarianism. In my research, I will argue that utilitarianism, contrary to its critics’ (mis)conception, has theoretical resources to take full account of commonsensical moral rules. I defend this thesis by distinguishing three types of utilitarianism: act-utilitarianism, rule-utilitarianism, and Hare’s two-level theory. Act-utilitarianism maintains that the agent is morally required to promote happiness. While it has a noble goal to achieve, it may indeed prescribe abhorrent actions whenever they are necessary for the realization of maximal happiness. In short, it may run afoul of commonsensical moral rules. In contrast, rule-utilitarianism insists that the commonsensical moral rules must be strictly followed by all means. Although this position might seem to be a merit to rule-utilitarianism, it has its flipside. Abandoning the pursuit of the maximal happiness for the preservation of commonsensical moral rules, it smacks of rule-worship and seems to contradict the welfare-promoting purpose of morality. Hare’s two level theory serves as a remedy for the defect of rule-utilitarianism. It maintains that while the commonsensical moral rules must be adhered to in most situations, they are never sacred and inviolable in a way rule-utilitarianism claims them to be. My research investigates how Hare’s two-level theory is to be distinguished from both act-utilitarianism and rule-utilitarianism and how it can fully accommodate commonsensical moral rules. It is original research in the sense that a new perspective on Hare’s two-level theory is provided to offer a solution to a long-standing problem that plagues utilitarianism.
Subjects
道德
日常道德規則
效益
效益主義
幸福
morality
utility
utilitarianism
happiness
commonsensical moral rules
SDGs

[SDGs]SDG16

Type
thesis
File(s)
Loading...
Thumbnail Image
Name

ntu-94-R90124012-1.pdf

Size

23.53 KB

Format

Adobe PDF

Checksum

(MD5):3a51b6c9b720e047adf1acdf5071947e

臺大位居世界頂尖大學之列,為永久珍藏及向國際展現本校豐碩的研究成果及學術能量,圖書館整合機構典藏(NTUR)與學術庫(AH)不同功能平台,成為臺大學術典藏NTU scholars。期能整合研究能量、促進交流合作、保存學術產出、推廣研究成果。

To permanently archive and promote researcher profiles and scholarly works, Library integrates the services of “NTU Repository” with “Academic Hub” to form NTU Scholars.

總館學科館員 (Main Library)
醫學圖書館學科館員 (Medical Library)
社會科學院辜振甫紀念圖書館學科館員 (Social Sciences Library)

開放取用是從使用者角度提升資訊取用性的社會運動,應用在學術研究上是透過將研究著作公開供使用者自由取閱,以促進學術傳播及因應期刊訂購費用逐年攀升。同時可加速研究發展、提升研究影響力,NTU Scholars即為本校的開放取用典藏(OA Archive)平台。(點選深入了解OA)

  • 請確認所上傳的全文是原創的內容,若該文件包含部分內容的版權非匯入者所有,或由第三方贊助與合作完成,請確認該版權所有者及第三方同意提供此授權。
    Please represent that the submission is your original work, and that you have the right to grant the rights to upload.
  • 若欲上傳已出版的全文電子檔,可使用Open policy finder網站查詢,以確認出版單位之版權政策。
    Please use Open policy finder to find a summary of permissions that are normally given as part of each publisher's copyright transfer agreement.
  • 網站簡介 (Quickstart Guide)
  • 使用手冊 (Instruction Manual)
  • 線上預約服務 (Booking Service)
  • 方案一:臺灣大學計算機中心帳號登入
    (With C&INC Email Account)
  • 方案二:ORCID帳號登入 (With ORCID)
  • 方案一:定期更新ORCID者,以ID匯入 (Search for identifier (ORCID))
  • 方案二:自行建檔 (Default mode Submission)
  • 方案三:學科館員協助匯入 (Email worklist to subject librarians)

Built with DSpace-CRIS software - Extension maintained and optimized by 4Science