Estimation of tree species richness from large area forest inventory data: Evaluation and comparison of jackknife estimators
Journal
Forest Ecology and Management
Journal Volume
255
Journal Issue
3-4
Pages
1002-1010
Date Issued
2008
Author(s)
Kleinn, C.
Abstract
Sample-based large area forest inventories are carried out in many countries specifically to provide information for forest policy and related decision making. In addition, ecologically meaningful information can be derived from the inventory data, including tree species richness. However, sample-based estimation of the total number of species is notoriously difficult. This study explores the strengths and weaknesses of large area forest inventory data in species richness estimation with a focus on the corresponding higher order jackknife estimators. Our test data set comes from a regional forest inventory in Northern Costa Rica. In our study, none of the kth order jackknife estimators reaches an asymptote and most have standard errors increasing with sample size. Inexplicably, the 4th and 5th order jackknives fail as estimators for our data-the estimates are almost identical to and even lower than the observed number of species. Additionally, higher order jackknives show large sampling variation. The 1st and 2nd order jackknives have small variation and thus are more reliable than higher order jackknives. The failure of the higher order jackknives suggests that the bias reduction theories underpinning the generalized jackknives are possibly not suited to the problem of species richness estimation. Care is, therefore, needed when interpreting a jackknife estimate of species richness. Various relevant practical issues in large area forest inventory implementation, particularly in the tropics, are discussed, including the accuracy of tree species identification and the presence of a certain percentage of unidentified tree individuals. These issues, obviously, pose an additional challenge in species richness estimation. © 2007 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
SDGs
Type
journal article