羅昌發Lo, Chang-fa臺灣大學:法律學研究所施明遠Shope, MarkMarkShope2010-05-052018-07-052010-05-052018-07-052009U0001-0508200911463600http://ntur.lib.ntu.edu.tw//handle/246246/179581This thesis will aim to generate a personality of Taiwan through a narrative of its unique legal history. The author will begin by identifying the community of Taiwan by discussing a historical image of the island both from an outsider’s and an insider’s perspective using a modern analysis of legal identity to try to shed light on its early nature and structure. This analysis, in turn, can help us catch a glimpse of the early identity of the community and the people associated with the community, ultimately creating the mental image, leading to a concrete definition, of the boundaries of legal persons and ruling identity. I will continue by discussing the legal system of the colonizers of the island. Arguments will point out that regardless of the regime that is on the island, local customs, both legal and cultural, significantly impact the regime and the strength of these customs ultimately define major aspects of the legal regime. I also claim that notwithstanding divergent ideas of the ruling class on the island, the legal regime that was customary to the island will clearly define major aspects of the Taiwanese identity. This thesis will not argue issues of sovereignty or other political issues, but will simply focus on the legal experiences of the people of the island.1. Introduction 1 . Pre-Dutch Era 3. Beginnings of Identity: Early Historical Precedents 3. Yizhou: Dissenting Opinions 4i. Content of the Seaboard Geographic Gazetter: Clues Establishing Distinctiveness 5ii. Reflections on Early Discovery and Occupation: The Land is Already Occupied 6v. Yizhou: Conclusion 7. Further Explorations and Historical Precedents 8. Sui Dynasty: We Saw a king. 8i. Brief History of the Concept of Chinese Geography: Imagined Geography 9. Later Recognition of Community – Penghu Islands: Reflections on the Meaning and Extent of Occupation 13. Reflections of the Ming Era (1368-1664): Japanese, Chinese, Fishermen, Merchants, and More Foreign Interested Parties. 15. Dutch Settlement and Koxinga (1624-1683) 19. Dutch Settlement (1624-1662) 19. Property/Ownership/Trade: The Idea of ‘Law’ Makes Advances 20i. Significance of “Indigenous People”: The Slow Separation of the Original Owners from Their Domain 21ii. Aspects of Government and Law: Early Documented Government Structure in Taiwan 22v. Local Dutch Administration 24. Missionary Work as a Source of Law: Pacify the Indigenes 25i. Clergymen Responsible for Civil Administration: Messengers of the Good Word or Civil Servants? 27ii. Placards as a Source of Law: A Short Analysis 29iii. Formosan Placard-book: Examples of Important Ordinances 30x. Dutch Era Conclusion 32. Koxinga (1662-1683) 33. Pre-invasion Issues: Another Foreigner Wants the Land 33i. Claim to Zheng’s Heroicism: Taiwanese, Japanese, Chinese, or other? 37ii. Koxinga Conclusion 38. Qing Dynasty (1684-1895) 39. Beginning Images: Early Qing Mentality Towards the Taiwanese 39. Maps as a Source of Territorial Awareness: Reflections on the Image of the Ruled v. the Image of the Ruler 41. Immigration Policy – Source of Control or Chaos? 43. Reflections on Aboriginal Rule During Early Qing Colonization 45. Transformation into Strategic Periphery: No Longer a Ball of Mud 47. The Aboriginal Integration – Cooked and Raw: Law Abiding or Criminal 49. The Dan-Xin Archives 51. Introduction: A Discussion of Significant Archives 52i. Code – The Written Origins of Law, but Rarelyited 52ii. Cultural Norms as a Source of Law: Traditional and Unique Forms of Self-rule and Paying Heed to the Local Values and Practices 53v. Cases: Examples of Court Cases 53. Case: Armed Robbery 54. Land Disputes – Introduction 55. Rent Resistance 56. Boundary Dispute 57. Kidnapping 59. Litigation Process: Access to All? 59. Filing a petition 60. Litigants 62i. Dan-Xin Final Thoughts 63. Qing Dynasty Conclusion 63. Transition – The Republic of Formosa? 65. Modern Era – Japan and the R.O.C. (1895-present) 67. Japanese Era Introduction (1895-1945) 68. Overview of the Administration 70i. Early Laws Dealing with the Problem of Banditry and Rebellion 73ii. Changing Image of Property Rights: The End of ‘Feudalism’? 75v. Constitution: Sources of Law 77. Court System: The Integration of a Western Style System 80i. Using a Modified System Tailored to the Island: Japanese Rule with Taiwanese Characteristics 81ii. Bandits, Social Order and Crime: The Mental Concept of Crime and Punishment 82iii. Indigenes Discontent: It’s Still our Island. 83x. Civil Law: Westernization 84. Postwar Taiwan: Freezing Constitutional Protection 85i. The Changing Identity of the Island 87ii. Japanese Era Conclusion 88. R.O.C. Introduction (1949-present) 88. Martial Law State, 1949-87: A Short Synopsis 89i. Democratization of Law, 1987-present 90ii. Government: A Modern Movement Towards Separation of Power and Meaningful Democracy 90v. Summary of the Justice system 91. The Legal Relations between Taiwan and Mainland China under the Constitution: Further Defining Identity From a Taiwanese Point of View 92. Conclusion 95application/pdf2022478 bytesapplication/pdfen-US臺灣法律Taiwancommunitylawidentitythesishttp://ntur.lib.ntu.edu.tw/bitstream/246246/179581/1/ntu-98-R96a21112-1.pdf