Winning quietly: Hong Kong educators’ resistance to National Security Education
Journal
Sociological Review
Date Issued
2023-01-01
Author(s)
Abstract
This study highlights the role of educators in the resistance to Hong Kong’s National Security Education (NSE) amidst waves of political repression in the wake of the anti-extradition movement of 2019–2020. Education reforms, teacher training and student assessment used to cultivate students’ creativity, critical thinking and independent thinking skills. NSE, which emphasises China’s perspective of knowledge construction, has contradicted long-standing pedagogies of teaching and learning. The research questions are: How do politically liberal educators navigate these changes? Do they conform and/or resist? Based on the study of social media and interviews with 22 politically liberal former and current teachers, school librarians, educators in public organisations and professors of teacher training programmes, I find that beneath the public transcripts of compliance in schools, there is a repertoire of ‘winning quietly’ among educators in Hong Kong by training students’ ‘civil society competence’ using less politically sensitive issues, working perfunctorily on NSE-related tasks, using metaphors, jokes and prayers to convey hidden messages, and allowing students to engage in resistance. Classrooms and private online groups remain the third space for atomised resistance. Outside Hong Kong, educators openly counter the ideological influence under NSE both individually and collectively, enabling an alternative to NSE that can reach students in Hong Kong. This study illuminates that authoritarian governments never fully control the stage, and it is too soon to tell whether their attempts to create obedient citizens will prevail.
Subjects
authoritarian regimes | education | everyday resistance | Hong Kong | transnationalism
Type
journal article